Thursday, January 27, 2011

Social Innovation and Social Finance Tour 2011: Reflection

Top Five Takeaways from the Tour 
(Part 2 of a 2-part series) 

Potluck Cafe: A successful social enterprise in Vancouver.
1. The momentum of social innovation and social finance is thriving in British Columbia. There are social enterprises popping out of every corner and several financial organizations to support them. It got me thinking: 

Why BC?  Why NOT Ontario? 

2. Current CRA laws restricting non-profit organizations and “social enterprises” (which don’t actually legally exist in Canada....YET) cause major complexity for organizations that are simply trying to find creative revenue streams aside from their dangerous dependence on donation dollars. This highlights the need for Canada to shadow the UK’s new legal entity, the “Community Interest Company” (CIC), or, the US’s “Low-profit Limited Liability Company” (L3C) to provide the opportunity to build legal, simple, and sustainable social enterprises. 

 Group discussions in Vancity's boardroom
3. Intermediaries are an essential prerequisite to growing the social finance field in Canada. 

What are intermediaries, might you ask? Think investment banks, but for social investment portfolios. 

We need organizations that can link investors who are interested in impact investing with the social entrepreneurs who are in dire need of funding. We need these intermediaries to manage the investment portfolios. Vancity, a cooperative bank in Vancouver, is a proven model that has invested millions into successful social enterprises. 

4. The Social Impact Bond model has tremendous potential for this country, but finding an appropriate process for measuring success will slow the model’s emergence in public policy. There are also many social and environmental issues that cannot be solved using this model. 

CONCLUSION: We need to look globally and think creatively about other possible social finance instruments. For lack of a better metaphor, let’s not put all our eggs in one basket. 

Founded by Stacey Corriveau
5. As Stacey Corriveau preached to the crowd: The government often chooses to deal with social issues now and claims they will deal with the environment once those are solved. 

NEWSFLASH: THE ENVIRONMENT IS A SOCIAL ISSUE. 


Monday, January 24, 2011

Social Innovation and Social Finance Tour 2011: Reflection

Top Five Highlights of the Tour
(Part 1 of a 2-part series) 

While it came and went quicker than I could imagine, the Social Innovation and Finance Tour brought about visionary conversations, outcomes, and networks.  Here are my top five highlights from the tour...

1. Ashoka Fellow, David Green, blowing away our 200 guests at the public event last Monday night. He presented his numerous yet distinct businesses that use groundbreaking technology to provide cost-effective solutions to sight- and hearing-loss for those suffering from poverty in the developing world. 

Celia Cruz, Director of Ashoka Canada
2. Nicole Rycroft (also an Ashoka Fellow!) presenting her organization, Canopy, which is responsible for the international “greening” of the Harry Potter books. Canopy is up to some fantastic new innovations, but you’ll have to wait and see Nicole’s next plan to change the paper industry in Canada... 

3. Bill Young explaining the convoluted path he had to take to build Social Capital Partners while confined by CRA and other legal constraints. Down-right hilarious. 

4. Derek Gent and the Vancity team proving that investing in social innovation can be both impactful and profitable as we sat in Vancity's beautiful boardroom, over-looking the ocean and the mountains.

5. All tour participants declaring personal action-statements as to how they will apply social finance to their organizations and help progress the movement in Canada. What a great way to end the Tour! 




Thank you to all those who made Ashoka's Social Innovation and Social Finance Tour a resounding success.  It was truly a pivotal three days for the movement's advancement in Canada.  

Social Innovation and Finance Tour in the news:

Other related articles:

Friday, January 14, 2011

Social Innovation and Social Finance: IT'S HERE!

Social Innovation and Finance Tour
Vancouver, BC Jan. 17-19, 2011


The day has finally arrived.  After extensive preparations and endless hours, I am now sitting in the airport ready to leave for what I know will be a groundbreaking event for the social innovation and social finance movement in Canada.  As part of the Ashoka Canada  family for the past few months, I have been fortunate enough to coordinate next week's events with the support of our partner organizations:  SiG National (Social Innovation Generation), Plan Institute, and Causeway Social Finance. 


Here are some of the topics we're going to be discussing with Canada's most active and educated leaders in the social finance and social innovation space:

  • Social Finance in BC
  • Social capital users and reflections from the supply-side
  • Impact Investing
  • How to bring about a mixed model of financing from grants to social capital?
  • Types of capital and when it's appropriate to use each type
  • Creating a public policy agenda
  • Looking at public policy through the disability lens
  • Scaling up proven innovation to create impact and durability

Monday evening, Jan. 17th, is our sold-out public event.  Four prominent social innovation leaders will provide both the global and Canadian perspective of social finance to 200 guests.  For more information and to grab a spot on the waiting list, visit http://openeventevening.eventbrite.com/

For those of you outside Vancouver, don't fret! I will MOST DEFINITELY post a follow-up to these events.  Looking forward to reporting back some positive and forward-looking results!

But for now, it's time to board the plane....

Monday, January 3, 2011

CARBON NEGATIVE? Seriously?

Why Fiji Water is going down the drain

I've spoken about my problem with water bottle consumption, and I've talked about the serious issue of greenwashing.  Today we get a taste of both.  Fiji, the already controversial water bottle giant, is facing a Class Action Law Suit for greenwashing!  

As a response to decreased sales, Fiji used a strategy many other companies are realizing profit from as well: they embellished the level of their environmental footprint.  The result: their sales increased by 12% in 2008, surpassing industry leader Evion. 

What was their strategy?  
It is the specific marketing scheme that makes this case so ridiculous.

image source: http://www.tapitwater.com/blog/fiji_water.jpg
Fiji actually claimed to have a negative carbon footprint.  This would imply that the company is removing more carbon pollution from the atmosphere than they released into it!  Think about how ludicrous this seems: all the plastic waste, transport pollution, manufacturing that emit carbon during a supply-chain process to sell water bottles cannot possibly be overridden by the amount of carbon Fiji could realistically remove.  Remember what I said several posts ago: Plastic can never fully disintegrate. 

And what is their defense?

Fiji Water's response is that they base their carbon calculations on the full life cycle of the water bottle.   This method, called "forward crediting", is a completely unaccredited way to measure carbon footprint.  As quoted in the complaint itself, "They simply claim credit for carbon removal that may or may not take place - up to several decades in the future."  Through various sustainable methods and new processes to decrease carbon emissions, Fiji claims it will reduce carbon emissions by 120%.  

And I'm sure the company will do just that......by losing the lawsuit, filing for bankruptcy, and closing up shop!

I hope companies use this case as a precedent for their own sustainability marketing campaigns.  People aren't stupid, and more than ever, we have a plethora of resources to get the straight facts.  As a lesson for us consumers, let's try to think more critically about the brands we choose.  Happy new year!






Monday, December 27, 2010

Social Impact Bond Model: 7 Easy Steps

A Triple Win.

As I’ve mentioned before, social finance can be a confusing topic to explain. I am often asked, “What do you mean by new modes of finance?” or, “what does it mean to create new financial instruments?” 

The Social Impact Bond is a perfect example of one of these new financial instruments. Within the past year, the Social Impact Bond Model has been put into practice in the UK. The Canadian Task Force on Social Finance is now analyzing the successes from the UK pilot project and is working to build a strategy that enables the necessary policy changes to spread Social Impact Bond investments throughout Canada. 

In its simplest form, here is how the model works: 

1. An idea arises for a new social purpose organization or innovative project that could help solve a specific problem that the government is currently spending our tax dollars on fixing. 

2. Problem: People may think the social innovation sounds like a good idea, but the government is not willing to invest in the project because it is much too risky (or, dare I say, too innovative for them). The idea is to find a way to incentivize the government to take risks on social and environmental innovations without the fear of losing tons of cash.  

Solution: 

3. Find an investor who is willing to take a risk on a social/environmental innovation. 

4. With the three parties (The investor, the government, and the mission-based organization/project),build an agreement on the terms of the investment including specific, quantifiable metrics.

5. The Investor loans $xxxxx.xx to the NPO, social enterprise, or other mission-based organization or project. 

6. After x number of years, the success of the social/environmental venture is measured against the initial set of benchmarks.

7. If the project is deemed successful, the government pays the investor the amount (or a portion of the amount) the government saves by otherwise spending that money on the status-quo ways of dealing with the given social problem. If the project is deemed unsuccessful, the investor receives nothing in return. (Deeming an innovation successful would mean that its outcomes meet the initial benchmarks set out in the terms of the investment).

SO, the government feels no financial risk, the social innovation finally has the financial freedom to experiment with potential solutions to serious social/environmental issues, and the investor receives a return if the outcome successfully saves the government money. WIN, WIN, and, you guessed it: WIN. 

Saturday, December 18, 2010

Warren Buffett: Leading by Example

Buffett's definition of "Success"

There are many ways to be a successful leader.  There are those who are outspoken and powerful, those who derive influence as the quiet leader, and those who lead by example.  In my experience, the latter has the greatest impact on his or her followers.  When an individual acts in way that is contrary to what is expected of him/her, or contrary to societal norms, they trigger a subconscious desire in others to follow this action.  Warren Buffett is living proof of the power of leading by example.  Started by Warren Buffett and Bill Gates, The Giving Pledge is inspiring wealthy individuals around the globe to donate half their wealth to philanthropic causes. 

The following is a public letter written by Buffett in which he explains his views on philanthropy, his commitment to giving, and his definition of success:

In 2006, I made a commitment to gradually give all of my Berkshire Hathaway stock to philanthropic foundations. I couldn’t be happier with that decision. Now, Bill and Melinda Gates and I are asking hundreds of rich Americans to pledge at least 50% of their wealth to charity. So I think it is fitting that I reiterate my intentions and explain the thinking that lies behind them. 

First, my pledge: More than 99% of my wealth will go to philanthropy during my lifetime or at death. Measured by dollars, this commitment is large. In a comparative sense, though, many individuals give more to others every day. Millions of people who regularly contribute to churches, schools, and other organizations thereby relinquish the use of funds that would otherwise benefit their own families. The dollars these people drop into a collection plate or give to United Way mean forgone movies, dinners out, or other personal pleasures. In contrast, my family and I will give up nothing we need or want by fulfilling this 99% pledge. 

Moreover, this pledge does not leave me contributing the most precious asset, which is time. Many people, including — I’m proud to say — my three children, give extensively of their own time and talents to help others. Gifts of this kind often prove far more valuable than money. A struggling child, befriended and nurtured by a caring mentor, receives a gift whose value far exceeds what can be bestowed by a check. My sister, Doris, extends significant person-to-person help daily. I’ve done little of this. What I can do, however, is to take a pile of Berkshire Hathaway stock certificates — "claim checks" that when converted to cash can command far-ranging resources — and commit them to benefit others who, through the luck of the draw, have received the short straws in life. 

To date about 20% of my shares have been distributed (including shares given by my late wife, Susan Buffett). I will continue to annually distribute about 4% of the shares I retain. At the latest, the proceeds from all of my Berkshire shares will be expended for philanthropic purposes by 10 years after my estate is settled. Nothing will go to endowments; I want the money spent on current needs. This pledge will leave my lifestyle untouched and that of my children as well. They have already received significant sums for their personal use and will receive more in the future. They live comfortable and productive lives. And I will continue to live in a manner that gives me everything that I could possibly want in life. 

Some material things make my life more enjoyable; many, however, would not. I like having an expensive private plane, but owning a half-dozen homes would be a burden. Too often, a vast collection of possessions ends up possessing its owner. The asset I most value, aside from health, is interesting, diverse, and long-standing friends. 

My wealth has come from a combination of living in America, some lucky genes, and compound interest. Both my children and I won what I call the ovarian lottery. (For starters, the odds against my 1930 birth taking place in the U.S. were at least 30 to 1. My being male and white also removed huge obstacles that a majority of Americans then faced.) My luck was accentuated by my living in a market system that sometimes produces distorted results, though overall it serves our country well. 

I’ve worked in an economy that rewards someone who saves the lives of others on a battlefield with a medal, rewards a great teacher with thank-you notes from parents, but rewards those who can detect the mispricing of securities with sums reaching into the billions. In short, fate’s distribution of long straws is wildly capricious. 

The reaction of my family and me to our extraordinary good fortune is not guilt, but rather gratitude. Were we to use more than 1% of my claim checks on ourselves, neither our happiness nor our well-being would be enhanced. In contrast, that remaining 99% can have a huge effect on the health and welfare of others. That reality sets an obvious course for me and my family: Keep all we can conceivably need and distribute the rest to society, for its needs. My pledge starts us down that course.
  Each day, more wealthy individuals are joining Buffett's and Gates's "The Giving Pledge", the latest being  Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg.  Click here to see The Giving Pledge's latest press release from December 8th.  It takes one person with a vision for action to make the seemingly impossible possible. 

Monday, December 13, 2010

Tackling Overconsumption vs. Sustainable Products

What is our answer? 

I think we can all agree that our environment is in some serious danger. I think where we tend to disagree is how to mitigate this danger, which is precisely the argument going on now in Cancun. The problem with Cancun is that loads of politicians are stuck dabbling back and forth and I’m genuinely concerned that no serious strategy will even come out of it all. What if our leaders don’t devise a solution at the next Environmental Summit? What about the one after that? 

It seems us citizens don’t have much control over the decisions made at these conferences, and if that’s the case, allow me to bring to your attention an environmental strategy argument that we consumers can absolutely take ownership of: 

I’ve been contemplating this for a while. Do we focus our attention on battling overconsumption, or do we channel our support towards sustainable product manufacturing? In an ideal world, we would have both strategies working simultaneously. But I’m trying to really delve deep here and think realistically, since our personal time and resources typically limit our arena of focus.

I am a huge supporter of the manufacturing of sustainable products. I truly see them as an investment (with my rate of return being as invaluable as the air we breathe). I believe there is absolutely room for growth in this market, but my concern is that this sustainable-product boom continues to contribute to our terrible overconsumption habits. The more I read about these habits, the more frightened I become about our world 20 years from now. 

Check this out: 

• Global oil production is currently about 81 million barrels a day and is predicted to fall to 39 million barrels a day by 2030 due to diminishing resources. 

Click here for image source
• The world's annual consumption of plastic materials has increased from around 5 million tonnes in the 1950s to nearly 100 million tonnes today. 

• The food we eat now typically travels between 1,500 and 3,000 miles from farm to our dinner plate. The distance had increased by up to 25 percent between 1980 and 2001.

• The average American buys 53 times as many products as someone in China and one American's consumption of resources is equivalent to that of 35 Indians. Over a lifetime, the typical American will create 13 times as much environmental damage as the average Brazilian. 

These are just a few examples of the thousands of ways our overconsumption habits are causing some serious damage. SO, as consumers, should we be investing more of our time, energy, and money feeding our consumption norms with sustainable products, or should we work on flat-out buying less? 

I don’t have a set opinion on this yet; this issue is vital for our environment’s survival and deserves more of my learning attention. I am unsure about whether we can even tackle this deeply engrained habit, and if it’s not possible, then maybe we should turn to green products for the answer. What I do know, however, is that our habits determine our destiny; I know that I am thinking more carefully each time I make a purchase. 

As one of my incredible past professors would say: 

“Almost everything you do is determined by your habits. We are all creatures of habits. Fortunately, all your habits are learned, learnable, and “droppable”. A habit is an automatic response to a stimulus and is (good or bad) something you do without much thought or effort. Once formed, your habits do not go away. They can only be replaced by new habits. You form your habits then your habits form you."

Overconsumption is one of the most difficult problems our global community must overcome to build a sustainable planet. If we listen to my professor, and we really do have the ability to replace our current habits...all we need to do is to start.